How Is Accident Reconstruction Used in a Commercial Truck Accident Case?
Posted on December 28, 2022 in Personal Injury
A serious commercial truck collision can leave competing accounts of what happened. Accident reconstruction uses physical evidence, measurements, vehicle information, and the laws of physics to analyze the sequence of a crash. It may help answer questions about speed, braking, vehicle paths, visibility, impact points, and driver response.
Reconstruction is not necessary in every truck accident claim. It is most useful when fault is disputed, the collision is severe, several vehicles are involved, or important details cannot be resolved from the police report and witness statements alone.
Evidence a Reconstructionist May Review
- Scene measurements, photographs, drone or survey data, tire marks, gouges, debris, and final vehicle positions
- Damage patterns and post-crash inspections of the tractor, trailer, and other vehicles
- Event data recorder, engine control module, telematics, GPS, and electronic logging device data
- Dash-camera, traffic-camera, surveillance, and in-cab video
- Driver logs, dispatch messages, maintenance records, cargo information, and weight or brake data
- Police reports, witness statements, weather, lighting, roadway design, and sight-distance information
The available data depends on the truck and carrier. Some systems record speed, braking, throttle, engine status, location, or driving time; others do not. A qualified analyst should identify the limits of the evidence rather than assume a device contains information it never captured.
What Reconstruction Can—and Cannot—Show
A reconstruction may estimate speed, calculate stopping distance, test whether a driver had time to react, or determine the likely order and direction of impacts. It can also compare a driver’s statement with the scene evidence. The analysis does not replace legal judgment, medical proof, or testimony about what people observed. Its reliability depends on sound methods and accurate inputs.
The Michigan State Police explains that its reconstruction specialists seek to determine how a collision occurred from the physical facts and the application of physics. Civil cases may use private experts working from many of the same categories of evidence.
Why Prompt Evidence Preservation Matters
Commercial vehicles may be repaired, returned to service, or sold. Electronic information can be overwritten, and carriers keep different records for different periods. A prompt preservation request can identify the truck, trailer, electronic systems, logs, video, inspection material, and other records that should not be destroyed. This is also important when the evidence may show truck driver fatigue or a maintenance problem.
Discuss a West Michigan Truck Crash
John D. Tallman evaluates serious commercial truck claims and determines when reconstruction or other expert analysis may be useful. Call 616-361-8850 or contact the firm for a free consultation. There is no attorney fee unless compensation is recovered.
Source: Michigan State Police Traffic Crash Reconstruction Unit.